data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/20adf/20adf7c88e8952954bc72b59506696d6cf5b9cce" alt="Home"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e90a9/e90a9b90fc41db7ad7b2d6049c61a6f544b9179b" alt="Bibliography by Author"
| |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/20adf/20adf7c88e8952954bc72b59506696d6cf5b9cce" alt="Home"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e90a9/e90a9b90fc41db7ad7b2d6049c61a6f544b9179b" alt="Bibliography by Author"
| |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/30cfe/30cfef5f5c70d5904564574d31cf354855fd1dea" alt="Topical Bibliography"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2457f/2457f3fc39eb2b5ce33ca273f138a8ab69cbc993" alt="Topical Bibliography"
This is not a definitive
bibliography. It simply lists the books and pamphlets on my book shelf. When
I've read something I put a brief annotation which gives my own impression or
synopsis of the work. I've also included hot links to Amazon wherever possible,
or else to the appropriate website. It comes in two versions, one in
alphabetical order of authors and the other, on this page, in which I've tried
to group the books by topic, though this is inevitably rather loose. In some
cases the same book appears in more than one section as many won't fit neatly
into my modernist categories! If I haven't made notes on a publication myself I
will try to include the publisher's blurb, in quotes.
Alternative Worship
[TOP]
Alternative worship is both an eclectic
'postmodern' style of worship and also an approach to being church. The
offerings below reflect both strands.
Baker,
Jonny & Gay, Doug 2003, Alternative Worship , London: SPCK.
Jonny Baker is one of the
leaders of Grace in Ealing, Doug Gay is is minister in the URC. This is a really
good and useful book: as well as a brief but good
introduction to the alt.worship scene this book contains a number of worship
resources based around the church year. There is some excellent material and a
CD-ROM is provided with words, images, movies and songs.
Detailed and seemingly fair
account of the success and failure of the Nine O’Clock Service (NOS) which was
started by Chris Brain at St Thomas, Crookes in Sheffield. Offers a warning for
the church about the abuses possible in fresh expressions of church but also
points to the pioneering work done by NOS.
Lings,
George (2001d),
The Enigma of Alternative Worship, “Encounters on the Edge 12”, Sheffield:
The Church Army.
George Lings visits a number of alternative worship
congregations including
Sanctuary (Bath),
Revive (Leeds) and
Visions (York). As
well as describing his experiences he makes an interesting distinction between
'Seeker' worship and Alternative worship: seeker takes the mysterious out of
evangelical presentation to outsiders; alternative puts ritual and worship at
the centre for insiders; seeker subjugates church culture to engagement with
secular culture, alternative rejoices in the the richness of church culture as a
way to live in secular culture; seeker puts evangelism at the top of its agenda,
alternative puts worship top; seeker tries to convince and persuade, alternative
is laid back and non-directive. Everyone will no doubt disagree with these
distinctions, but I find them salutary and helpful; after all, as the
statistician George Box put it, "All models are wrong. Some models are useful."
Lomax,
Tim & Moynagh, Michael 2004,
Liquid Worship, Grove Worship Series W181,
Cambridge: Grove Books.
In liquid worship members of the congregation
choose which of a number of prayer stations or worship zones they will visit,
and in which order. After exploring a number of examples and options for liquid
worship—whether for a small group or whole church; whether for a whole service
or part of it—Lomax & Moynagh explore the rationale for this kind of approach.
They claim that it can have a number of positive benefits including reducing
self-indulgence, offering a chance to develop good liturgical principles;
offering possibilities for all-age worship and recognising that the Spirit
‘never leaves identical fingerprints’. They also argue that liquid worship
encourages us to re-think our notions of community and can help us develop
closer and more authentic communities. They end by suggesting some principles
for getting started with liquid worship. The accompanying
website gives plans of a layout for liquid worship and an example of a
Mothering Sunday service.
Roberts, Paul 1999,
Alternative Worship in
the Church of England,
Grove Worship Series W155, Cambridge: Grove Books.
Roberts characterises alternative worship as
having the following characteristics: multi-media environment resulting from
intense creativity; use of visuals; use of sound; collaborative leadership;
breadth of liturgical resources. He traces the history of the movement from its
roots in NOS and then considers the underlying philosophy, seeing the inevitable
parallels with postmodernist approaches to text and the importance of shared
interpretations of the Bible. He ends with a consideration of the role of
alt.worship within the more formal and regulated structures of the C of E.
Rollins, Peter 2006,
How (not) to Speak of God ,
London: SPCK.
I loved this book. It's in two
parts: the first looks at the nature of God and how we might know/encounter him;
the second gives a number of 'scripts' from sessions of Ikon, an alternative
worship community in Belfast, of which Rollins is a leader. Pete Rollins teaches
philosophy and brings interesting insights to this book. Rollins starts with two
epigrams, one from Wittgenstein, the other from his charismatic evangelical
background: "What we cannot speak about we must pass over in silence." and
"God is the one subject of whome we must never stop speaking." He finds a
resolution of these two apparent opposites in an apophatic approach to God—that we cannot ever know about God
but that we can experience God. He sees Christianity as a/theistic, citing
Anselm, amongst others, on his side: "Therefore, Lord, you are not merely that
than which a greater cannot be thought: you are something greater than can be
thought."
This sense of radically engaged
unknowing pervades the book. Rollins dissolves the debate between the
transcendence and immanence of God by asserting that God is immanent and it is
the brilliance of his closeness which leads us to experience Him as
transcendent, just a really bright light will blind us. There is much more to
engage and startle the reader. You don't have to agree but if it doesn't make
you think afresh I'll be surprised.
Sylvan, Rob 2005,
Trance Formation
, London: Routledge.
A
fascinating book in which the author explores the spiritual aspects of rave
culture. Sylvan did his doctorate looking at the African tribal religious roots
of rock music. When he became involved in the rave scene in the US her decided
to do some research. He suggests that rave culture has seven characteristics:
A combination of sacred and secular; Expression within the arts;
Expression within popular culture; Emphasis on experience over content;
The central importance of the body; Use of digital technology, multimedia, and
global communication systems; and Postmodern, hybrid, cut-and-past nature. The
similarities with some alternative worship values will be no surprise, given the
roots of the alternative worship movement.
Tarrant, Ian 2003,
Scripture-Based
Liturgies,
Grove Worship Series W 175, Cambridge: Grove Books.
Tarrant presents a selection of liturgies which
are strongly based on particular passages of scripture. The aim is to match the
narrative structure of the Bible text with a corresponding liturgical structure.
This is an approach of used and developed in alternative worship. Five sample services follow: Luke 24, an ecumenical Easter communion; John 6, a
communion liturgy; Acts 8, service of the word with baptism; Philippians, an
office; Hebrews, morning prayer. The accompanying
website gives further examples and resources.
Tarrant,
Ian & Dakin, Sally 2004,
Labyrinths and Prayer Stations, Grove Worship Series
W180, Cambridge: Grove Books.
Tarrant & Dakin start by offering
a few definitions and then move into a brief history of labyrinth and prayer
journey, such stations of the cross, in Christian worship. The rest of their
booklet is practical, offering ideas and encouragement for creativity. They end
with some examples of labyrinths they have created. An excellent introduction to
the topic. The
accompanying
website gives further examples and resources.
Chapters from Jeremy Fletcher ('Text, Authority and
Ritual in the Church of England'), Maggi Dawn ('The Art of Liturgy'), Pete Ward
('Personalized Ritual'), Anthony Reddie ('Black Styles, Rituals and Mission for
the 21st century'), Ana Draper ('Curiosity... Gave the Cat Nine Lives'), Mike
Riddell ('Deep Currents of the Heart') and Jonny Baker ('Ritual as Strategic
Practice').
Base
Ecclesial Communities
[TOP]
Base Ecclesial Communities started in South
America. The leading exponents of this approach in the UK is the
New Way of
Being Church movement. All of the publications below come from them.
A series of short pieces
including a brief account of New Way in Plymouth (see Summers 2003), a small
group on Broadwater Farm, working with non-church goers, moving to dialogue
sermons, communities of households in the Northampton area, free lunches and
other ‘gospel projects’ in Cambridge, church in a pub in Sheffield, a small
group in Tiptree.
Advice on developing and growing
small Christian communities of the base ecclesial type. Includes a check list of
pointers and an account of the New Way Pastoral Cycle:
Experience—Analysis—Reflection—Action—Celebration—Experience…
Another anthology, with a
Methodist minister who learned by listening, building A New Way in South Devon,
doing a social audit in an inner city, change catalysed by the arrival of
refugees, Peter Price thinking about the future, change in service pattern
leading to community change, being church on a traffic island, being at the
heart of community-led regeneration, a pets’ service, exploring forgiveness
amongst the unchurched, the need to take risks.
Sets out the need for interactive
communication between church and community, seeing small groups as complementary
to the gathered church. It looks for a ministry capable of constructing local
theologies which will lead to effective engagement with the local community.
“[Small groups] are not better
than other church, social or political groups. It is simply that their function
and their focus of gathering or meeting is to seek the welfare of the
neighbourhood.” (p. 8) There are certain ministries which need to be exercised
within the small group—welcome, time keeping, co-ordination, memory
recollection, worship, biblical reflection, news sharing & celebration. Looks at
each and ends by reflecting on the pastoral cycle.
A series
of brief bible studies on Matthew’s gospel, divided according to the Revised
Common Lectionary. Each study contains an invitation to tell personal stories
around the theme, a brief comment on the text, and invitation to reflection and
action and a suggestion for prayer.
Sichel,
Stephen and Slessarev, Helene 2001,
A New Bridge: The Contribution of
Broad-Based Organising and
Saul Alinksy Goes to Church, Resource
Booklet 10, Groton, Suffolk: New Way Publications.
An
introduction to broad-based organising, the process pioneered by Saul Alinsky in
Chicago in the 1940s. Stephen Sichel offers some insights and gives brief case
studies of a few British broad-based organisations, which have usually been
started by church groups but broadened to include community and other
faith-based groups. Helen Slessarev writes about Alinsky in an article
originally published in “The Sojurner.” [May be out of print.]
Tells the story of introducing
New Way into St Barnabas in inner city Plymouth. Doesn’t go into much detail and
looks at principles of base communities—neighbourhood groups, as they call them.
Also gives a brief note on his current work with Rattery in the South Hams,
Devon, a scattered village of about 500 with an electoral roll of 17, mainly
1662.
Bible Study
[TOP]
Reading and studying the Bible in a
postmodern world is different from doing the same thing in a modern world. The
are a number of old and new ways of engaging with scripture which may resonate
with a postmodern sensibility.
In three parts. The first looks at the demise of
modernism and suggests that we should ‘fund’ the components out of which a new
world can be imagined. The second part looks to find an evangelical (as an
adjectival form of ‘gospel’) imagination, focusing on memory, covenant and hope.
In the third part six pieces of exegesis are offered as example of the approach,
honouring the ‘little story’ at the expense of the ‘great story’.
Ingram
argues that the ambiguity of Ecclesiastes is intentional and very much in tune
with postmodern sensibility. For instance, we can read 1:4-11 as showing the
futility of life or as the wonder of creation. Both readings are valid.
Bible study without Bibles? That's what Janet Lees recommends. In this book she
offers an approach which enables collaborative work within a group to build up
shared remembered versions of biblical texts. By focusing on what is remembered
people also come to share their own stories, especially those which resonate
with the text. Lees offers a number of different ways of working with remembered
texts, some giving more aids to memory than others. She uses this approach in
Sunday worship. I haven't but I have found it to be very effective in small
group work. There is an egalitarian feel to the approach which helps everyone to
engage and participate.
Cafe Church
[TOP]
Cafe Church is a bit of a catch-all title
describing a range of approaches from conventional worship done with people
seated at small tables to cafes in secular premises open several days a week.
Barbara Glasson is a Methodist minister. She
started 'Somewhere Else', usually known as the 'bread church' in Liverpool.
There, in rooms above a radical bookshop in the heart of Liverpool, people come
together to make bread and also sometimes to study, pray and worship together.
What makes the bread church special is its inclusiveness and the depth of
conversation and sharing which is engendered by the act of bread making. Barbara
Glasson has now moved on to another post and this book is a series of reflections on community
and what it is to be church, based around the process of making bread. Do not
expect to find too many facts or details about how Somewhere Else actually
operates or its history. Instead, let Barbara confront you with a vision of
God's kingdom which may be uncomfortable to some but which I found inspiring and
challenging.
An
account of two cafe churches, Soul Cafe in Chester Green, Derby and
Cafe Church @ The Well in Sheffield. Soul Cafe runs once a month from 8:00
pm to 10:00 pm in the church building of St Paul, Chester Green. According to
Lings, the evening has the feel of a folk club with songs, chat and
informality. Soul Cafe has two another, related, event each month—Soul Space,
where people can meet to explore further—and an Open Mic
night two or three times a year where anyone can come and contribute. Cafe Church at the Well, the
worship complex of St Bartholomew's in Sheffield met monthly at 5:00 pm but
numbers quickly dropped and it struggled to continue. Lings ends by reflecting
on the nature of cafe church.
In
this issue George Lings visits Cafeplus+ in Haddenham and Pendleford Oasis
run by St Paul, Tettenhall in Wolverhampton. Cafeplus+ meets once a month in the
village hall and runs from 09:30 am to 12:30 pm. There are a number of spaces
available in the hall and Cafeplus+ provides a quiet space, room for teenagers,
a large hall for displays as well as the cafe. Pendleford Oasis is different; it
is a permanent church-run cafe built in a new housing estate as part of a church
and community initiative. Food and drink are cheap and Fair Trade and community
groups meet there regularly. Lings then offers a taxonomy of cafe church,
depending on purpose and 'target audience' on the one hand and location on the
other.
Lings,
George 2010a,
The X Factor Within: Rural Cafe Church
“Encounters on the Edge 45”, Sheffield: The Church Army.
I'm a bit biased about this one since it's about
the fresh expression which I oversee: Xpressions cafe in the Chet Valley
Benefice in South Norfolk. George came to visit us twice and his incessant
gentle questioning was hugely helpful to the whole team. It seems to me that he
has provided a very fair reflection of what we do and why we do it. He also
offers some helpful theoretical understandings and challenges us to think about
how we can take the Cafe forward.
Cell Church
[TOP]
The principle of Cell Church is that small
groups are the basic unit of church and that as they grow in size they will
divide (as biological cells do). The idea came from the Far East and has spread
throughout the world. There is a huge literature on cell church, some of it
quite prescriptive and modernist in style.
An account of St John’s,
Bradford’s move to cell church. Their version of the ‘four Ws’ is welcome,
worship, word, works (cf Lings 2003b). The book is good on principles but
sometimes a bit short on detail.
Hopkins,
Bob (ed) 2000,
Cell Church Stories as Signs of Mission, Grove Evangelism
Series Ev 51, Cambridge: Grove Books.
Hopkins argues that cell is an important strand in
church life (Acts 2:24—met in homes & temple) and offers this definition of
church: “a Jesus community of disciple-making disciples.” The rest of the study
offers four case studies, written by local leaders, showing how cell can be used
flexibly in different contexts at Holy Apostles, Leicester (cell outreach on
estate); St Alkmund’s, Derby (youth cell in non-cell church); St Mark’s, Haydock
(‘big bang’ transition from home groups to cells) & Harvest, Margate.
Lings,
George (1999c),
Has Church Reached Its Cell Buy Date?, “Encounters on the Edge 03”,
Sheffield: The Church Army.
"In the paramilitary town of Lisburn, Northern
Ireland, Capt. Martin Garner (CA) began a Cell Church Plant in an attempt to
reach beyond religious and tribal labels. This issue tells this story alongside
answering the questions “What is cell?”, “Where is it rightly different from
existing church?” and “How do cell and existing church work together?”"
Lings,
George (2003b),
Soft Cell,
“Encounters on the Edge 20”, Sheffield: The Church Army.
Account of the cell experiment
conducted at St Winfrid’s, High Wycombe by Paul Bayes (appointed National
Advisor for Mission & Evangelism in 2004). Instead of adopting the recommended
‘big bang’ approach to introducing cell principles, they adopted a parallel
approach, starting with one cell and adding others when demand from existing
members required. Cells use the Faith Community Baptist Church of Singapore
approach with emphasis on a set of core values—Jesus at the centre; everyone in
ministry; every member growing; multiplication; sacrificial love, loving
community & honesty. They also use welcome, worship, witness & word rather than
the more usual Western versions (see Astin 2002).
Lings,
George (2005d),
Rural Cell Church: A New Wayside Flower “Encounters on the Edge 28”, Sheffield:
The Church Army.
"For fresh expressions of
church, is it better to start something alongside the traditional
rather than reform it radically? Cells seem to be a natural
home for people coming to faith through process evangelism courses.
However, how well does cell suit the countryside?
Could it be significant for the rural church of the future?
I went to see…"
Church Planting
[TOP]
Church Planting is not a precise term. For
some it means taking the 'DNA' of an existing church and cloning it elsewhere.
For others it is about replicating the DNA in a rather more flexible and
contextualised way.
Carey,
George et al 1991, Planting New Churches , Guildford: Eagle.
A critique of current church structures. Down claims
that the parish system is geared to maintenance and that it hinders mission. He
writes from a conservative charismatic and modernist perspective and draws from
his own experiences in Fountain of Life and from others such as Carpenter’s Arms
in Deal, Oak Tree Fellowship in Acton and Norwich Community Church. He also
argues that maintenance churches need pastoral leadership while missionary
churches need apostolic leadership. The traditional parish church will not
change—one strategy is to leave it; another is to build a new church alongside
the old.
Lings,
George & Murray, Stuart 2003, Church Planting: Past, Present & Future,
Grove Evangelism Series Ev61, Cambridge: Grove Books.
A sober
review of church planting by most of the major denominations and new churches
during the 1990s, together with a reasonably optimistic look forward to its
possibilities in the future. [May now be unavailable]
Emerging Church
[TOP]
Emerging Church is another imprecise term.
Nowadays it is often used as a blanket term for any form of church which aims to
engage with postmodern unchurched culture. Ian Mobsby argues that only the only
forms of emerging church which come under the Fresh Expressions banner are
alternative worship groups, cafe church, and network church. Others would
disagree!
I found this a difficult book to
read. Brewin is a leader of Vaux, an alternative worship community in London and
includes some examples of their work throughout the book. He is looking to build
a radically emerging church and turns to complex systems theory as a framework
to organise some of his thoughts. He doesn't see alternative worship communities
as emerging church as they are not 'conjunctive'. It felt a bit polemical to me;
Brewin is struggling for a new vision of church, which is good, but this didn't
inspire me in the way that it should have.
An
excellent book. Gibbs and Bolger very firmly identify emerging churches with
postmodern churches and then offer nine areas which they have in common. The
book is based on a five-year project in which they interviewed 50 emerging
church leaders in UK & US. A feature of the book is the mini-autobiographies of
those leaders, which gives added depth to the work.
They
identify three core practices: identifying with the life of Jesus; transforming
secular space; and commitment to community as a way of life. These lead to six
other shared areas: welcoming the stranger; serving with generosity;
participating as producers; creating as created beings; leading as a body; and
taking part in spiritual activities. The book is enlivened throughout by
frequent quotes from the practitioners.
Surveys differences between ‘seeker-sensitive’
(modern) and emerging (postmodern) approaches. Helpful thoughts on relationship
between Jesus (positive affect) and Christians (negative affect) as perceived by
emerging generations. Sections on worship, preaching (notes that for moderns:
FACT influences BELIEF influences BEHAVIOUR, whereas for emerging culture:
EXPERIENCE influences BEHAVIOUR influences BELIEF), evangelism (focus on being a
co-worker with Jesus in the kingdom as a way of finding purpose in life) &
leadership. Quite a strong conservative evangelical bias and written for a
similar audience though much of use for others.
Larson, Bruce & Osborne, Ralph 1970, The Emerging
Church, Waco, TX: Word Books.
The first book I have found
to use the term ‘emerging church’. It's out of print now though you can get it
from various second-hand dealers. Larson & Osborne do not use the term as we use
it today; their book is basically a look at church in the 1970s and an attempt
to discern some of the emerging trends. A quote: ‘Renewal is a concept foreign
to the emerging Church. Renewal implies that the Church was once what God
intended it to be and that our task is to bring back that golden age. From
its earliest beginnings until now, the Church has been in the process of
becoming, and it shall always be so. If the Church is true to its Lord, it
may never properly say that it has “emerged.”’ Key themes are new forms of
worship, development of lay ministry and so on.
Murray, Stuart 2004,
Post-Christendom: Church and Mission in a Strange New World (After Christendom) , Milton Keynes:
Paternoster.
Stuart Murray is an
Anabaptist and writes from a radical non-establishment perspective. He documents
the rise and fall of Christendom and notes a number of shifts which are now
happening. The church, he argues, is moving centre to margins; from majority to
minority; from settlers to sojourners; from privilege to plurality; from control
to witness; from maintenance to mission; and from institution to movement. It's
a penetrating analysis which needs to be heeded by the church.
Rollins, Peter 2006,
How (not) to Speak of God ,
London: SPCK.
I loved this book. It's in two
parts: the first looks at the nature of God and how we might know/encounter him;
the second gives a number of 'scripts' from sessions of Ikon, an alternative
worship community in Belfast, of which Rollins is a leader. Pete Rollins teaches
philosophy and brings interesting insights to this book. Rollins starts with two
epigrams, one from Wittgenstein, the other from his charismatic evangelical
background: "What we cannot speak about we must pass over in silence." and
"God is the one subject of whome we must never stop speaking." He finds a
resolution of these two apparent opposites in an apophatic approach to God—that we cannot ever know about God
but that we can experience God. He sees Christianity as a/theistic, citing
Anselm, amongst others, on his side: "Therefore, Lord, you are not merely that
than which a greater cannot be thought: you are something greater than can be
thought."
This sense of radically engaged
unknowing pervades the book. Rollins dissolves the debate between the
transcendence and immanence of God by asserting that God is immanent and it is
the brilliance of his closeness which leads us to experience Him as
transcendent, just a really bright light will blind us. There is much more to
engage and startle the reader. You don't have to agree but if it doesn't make
you think afresh I'll be surprised.
Evangelism & 21st Century Mission Background
[TOP]
The research into the spirituality of those
who do not go to church reveals how scared so many unchurched people are of
being 'brainwashed' by Christians. This section contains links to some of this
research. Given what has been discovered, is there any future for evangelism in
the 21st century? Some people think so and you can find the fruits of their
labours here.
Excellent survey of a wide range
of contemporary approaches to evangelism including Alpha, Emmaus, other process
evangelism courses, community ministry, Natural Church Development, cell church,
church planting and the search for spirituality. It offers a practical and
even-handed critique of the different approaches, arguing that local churches
must find the balance of approaches which works best for their circumstances.
The first three chapters are from
Nick Spencer and Yvonne Collins, outlining their research with those who have
little or no contact with church. The second part of the collection consists of
four 'responses'. Ann Richards looks at contemporary spirituality and the
evangelistic encounter; Mark Ireland offers practical suggestions for the local
church; Rob Frost explores alternative spirituality; and Stephen Croft looks at
listening and speaking in contemporary evangelism.
Donovan worked with the Masai in
Kenya. Starting with his realisation that, for all the good things that the
mission was doing, there were no conversations about God with the Masai, he
realised that, “Evangelization is a process of bringing the gospel to people
where they are, not where you would like them to be.” So he decided to just go
and talk with them. Putting practice before theory, he discovers the importance
of stripping away all the cultural accretions of Western Christendom and
retranslating the gospel into the culture of the people. Despite its focus on
Africa in the 1960s, this is a seminal book for approaching emerging church and
postmodern proclamation.
Finney, John
2004, Emerging Evangelism , London, Darton, Longman & Todd.
Finney argues that there are
three approaches to evangelism in the Bible, focusing on kerugma, euangelion and
musterion. All three are needed for a balanced approach. He offers a brief and
interesting history of evangelism up to 1980 and then looks at the ‘new
evangelism’ with its emphasis on nurture groups, and nurture courses such as
Alpha & Emmaus (Finney was one of the authors of Emmaus). He then moves on to
explore the implications of ‘evangelising Athens’, which requires us to start
with something other than sin and forgiveness such as creation, hospitality of
mystery (sample addresses on these themes are provided in an appendix). The new
monasticism (such as St Thomas, Sheffield) follows, and some helpful thoughts on
leadership, ritual and the emerging church.
Hollinghurst, Steve 2003,
New Age, Paganism and Christian Mission, Grove
Evangelism Series Ev64, Cambridge: Grove Books.
A review of New Age and Pagan beliefs, showing
their similarities and differences. Hollinghurst also offers some helpful
suggestions on ways of connecting with new agers and pagans and how the gospel
might be authentically shared.
An A4 photocopiable
workbook with lots of good ideas and resources. Sections include: The Emerging
Spiritual Age; Listening to the World Around Us; Rites of Passage; Times and
Seasons; Developing the Church as the Spiritual Focus of the Community;
Wholeness and Healing; Going Out to Our Communities; Sacred Britain; Being With
People of Alternative Spiritualities; Moving Into Action. There are also a
number of good and pointed cartoons from Chris Morgan and also the questionnaire
that Yvonne Richmond used for her Beyond the Fringe research.
Really interesting book about medium-sized
communities (between cell and congregation) which exist for a specific
mission-focused purpose. Clusters developed in St Thomas, Crookes in Sheffield.
According to the book, "Clusters gain identity and purpose from a united mission
vision, being called to a clear geographic or network focus and engaging with
the social patterns of that culture and context." (p. [6]) Members of a cluster
will probably belong to different cell group or different congregations because
they are chosen (often self-selecting) on the basis of shared interest. The book
offers case studies of a number of different implementations of the cluster
principle.
Fascinating book looking at the
methods of missionaries like St Patrick, arguing that many of their methods are
appropriate for a postmodern generation. Hunter shows the differences between
the Celtic and Roman approaches and suggests that the Celts relied on
hospitality and a group-based outreach. They were offering an atmosphere of
constant prayer (though specific prayers for many of life’s daily tasks), a
radical understanding of the culture of those amongst whom they worked and an
acknowledgement of the ‘excluded middle’ (from “The Flaw of the Excluded Middle”
by Paul Heibert, Missiology: An International Review 10:1, 1982, which argues
that enlightenment Christianity focuses only on earth (realm of reason) and
heaven (realm of sacred) and ignores the middle ground (realm of superstition).
Yet increasingly, the new age is offering people solace here. The church should
offer authentic comfort by engaging with people where they are now, just as the
Celtic missionaries did.
Written in McLaren’s easy
narrative style this book explores how to do evangelism by being a spiritual
friend, walking with somebody on their journey, not trying to lead but just to
be there listening and caring. He illustrates this with the story of his
interaction, largely through e-mails, with ‘Alice’, who he met briefly and who
he nurtured through her struggle to faith.
Savage, Collins & Mayo
interviewed 135 young people, mainly between the ages of 15 and 25, in 26 focus
groups throughout England. Of these, 52% were female, 48% male; 94% were white,
6% Black or Asian; 60% defined themselves as non-Christian, 40% as Christian.
Their findings showed significant differences between this generation and those
which preceded it. For instance, researchers have often spoken of a hunger for
spirituality in Gen-X and Boomer people—a ‘God-shaped hole’ in their lives. None
was found for the Gen-Y young people in this study. Instead, the major finding
was of what they call a ‘happy midi-narrative’: “My aim to be happy will be
realised through me being myself, and connecting to others and the universe
(without harming them). As I do this, I will create a meaningful and happy life.
This happiness is meaningful in itself; it is the Ideal." They also look at what
is absent (God, religion, romance, fear of death, sin, etc.) from the happiness
narrative and what is present in it (family, friends, celebrity, caring for
life, etc.). The key importance of soap operas, music and clubbing are also
noticed and commented on.
Basic
account of Willow Creek approach, which focuses on non-Christians, designing
‘seeker-friendly’ services (more like presentations) which are very
professionally produced and which attract thousands each Sunday. The main
Christian service is held mid-week. Simmonds offers his reactions to the
experience, together with some reflections on the implications for British
churches.
Survey of non-believers’ beliefs, based on focus
group discussions. Christians are seen as hypocritical and intolerant—though
individual Christians are not usually perceived as such; , belief is a private
‘pick and mix’ affair which cannot be articulated. Science—which is not
understood—has disproved religion. But many have had ‘spiritual’ experiences,
which they are reluctant to speak of. They regret falling public standards of
morality and wonder if the church might help improve things.
This book attempts to offer
'double listening': listening to the world and listening to God. Each section
(God; Christianity; Christians; Church) has two chapters. The first is by
Spencer outlining some of his research with Beyond Belief (see above) and
also Yvonne Richmond's Beyond the Fringe project in Coventry. In the
second Tomlin offers a theological response and seeks to hear what God is
speaking into the situation today. An interesting concept and well worth
reading.
Sylvan, Rob 2005,
Trance Formation , London: Routledge.
A
fascinating book in which the author explores the spiritual aspects of rave
culture. Sylvan did his doctorate looking at the African tribal religious roots
of rock music. When he became involved in the rave scene in the US her decided
to do some research. He suggests that rave culture has seven characteristics:
A combination of sacred and secular; Expression within the arts;
Expression within popular culture; Emphasis on experience over content;
The central importance of the body; Use of digital technology, multimedia, and
global communication systems; and Postmodern, hybrid, cut-and-past nature. The
similarities with some alternative worship values will be no surprise, given the
roots of the alternative worship movement.
About
change, loss & responsibility—“There is no growth without change and there is no
change without loss” (p15). The call is to evangelise the heart of the church
and to do things differently. One example: Thorpe had three congregations—BCP,
family service & evening service; each had its own leadership team and all
decisions relating to life and ministry within that congregation were taken by
the congregation. In effect, three different expressions of church. There is a
centrally agreed vision but each congregation is encouraged to develop its own
mission statement.
Not really emerging church, but
often referred to by American emerging church writers. Warren argues that church
health is the key issue, leading naturally to growth. Despite the fact that many
US churches have adopted Saddleback’s principles as a programme, Warren focuses
on process rather than programme. The book is full of consultant-style models,
mnemonics and aphorisms (see table on p119) and has some sound common sense
about dealing with the unchurched.
Writing for American evangelicals, Webber argues
that of the five ‘paradigms’ of church history (ancient, medieval, reformation,
modern, postmodern) the ancient is of most relevance to the postmodern. He then
offers a primer on Christ (focusing on Christus Victor), church, worship,
spirituality & authority. Despite its constant references to postmodernity, I
found the approach to be disappointingly modernist in many ways (emphasis on a
knowable metanarrative, etc.)
Fresh Expressions: Case Studies
[TOP]
There's nothing like reading a practical
account of how people actually go about trying to find new ways to be church in
the 21st century. Here are some accounts.
Clare Dalpra visits a number of Fresh Expressions
dedicated the culture of adults with a learning disability (and their carers)
including Fenland Community
Church and
Focus Service: Sheffield Church. She also reflects on the learning such
churches offer to other Fresh Expressions.
Sally was a member of the team which produced
the Mission-Shaped Church report and has practical experience of fresh
expressions in the countryside. She is aware of the particular issues facing the
rural church but she does not exaggerate them. The book recognises the power of
inherited expressions in the countryside and argues strongly for the mixed
economy—we should nurture inherited church and also start fresh expressions for
those who would not be at home with traditional styles.
The book is very practical, full of case
studies and stories of rural initiatives. There is enough to encourage anyone in
the countryside that change and growth are possible with prayer, faith and hope;
plus a fair amount of perseverance. Sally also offers some useful thoughts on
how to restructure the church for mission in the countryside.
This is a very useful book. It offers a good
introduction to the principles and practice behind mission-shaped church and
will be of particular use to anyone who is in rural ministry or who just has a
passion to see the church grow in the countryside.
Lings,
George 2000a,
Across the Pond, “Encounters on the Edge 6”, Sheffield: The
Church Army.
Account of outreach activity in Blackheath onto an
estate. Charts the changes in strategy from ‘Come’ to ‘Go’ and from ‘doing to’
to ‘working with’.
Lings,
George 2002a,
The Eden Puzzle, “Encounters on the Edge 14”, Sheffield: The
Church Army.
The
Eden Project in Manchester
is part of the Message Trust.
It grew out of a big
youth event run by Andy Hawthorne and ‘The Worldwide Message Tribe’ in Manchester in 2000.
At the time of writing there
were 10 teams of full-time & volunteer youth workers who move to estates in
Manchester and live and work in deprived areas. The scheme has now been extended
nationwide. They aim to partner with local
churches and also to grow youth congregations where appropriate.
Lings,
George 2002b,
Mass
Planting, “Encounters on the Edge 16”, Sheffield: The Church Army.
Story of anglo-catholic Damian
Feeney, who sees the Eucharist as the heart of mission and spent 18 months doing
a Sunday Eucharist at Asda in Preston, at 10:00 in the 30 minutes before the
store opened. It was also broadcast over the store tannoy. The ministry also had
a prophetic edge, as when the harvest service at the store challenged shoppers
about fair trading. Father Damian then moved to a pub for a year and then into a
newly-built local Millennium Hall with a 5:30 Eucharist on a Saturday evening
(between Grandstand & going out to the pub).
Lings,
George 2004b,
New
Housing, New Partnerships? “Encounters on the Edge 23”, Sheffield: The
Church Army.
Lings has always been sceptical
about ecumenical church plants. Here he investigates two multi-denomination (not
quite the same thing) developments on new housing estates. By respecting one
another’s traditions fruitful partnerships can be created. Other key qualities
are emphasis on community, shared & lay ministry, leaders with overseas mission
experience and prime sites for development on the new estates.
Lings,
George 2004d,
Oasis: Work in Progress “Encounters on the Edge 24”, Sheffield:
The Church Army.
OASIS is
Edinburgh-based, working with working people. It has a link person in each of 80
offices in the city and began by running lunchtime talks at St Cuthbert’s
Church. It then moved to running seminars on relevant topics, such as the
introduction of e-commerce. They also run BAE (Business Alpha Edinburgh). Some
move on to find an existing church but for others OASIS is their church. Lings
also looks at Oasis Uxbridge, started after June Hughman, the incumbent, came
across the Edinburgh experience on a sabbatical.
Murray,
Stuart & Wilkinson-Hayes, Anne 2000,
Hope From the Margins: New Ways of Being
Church, Grove Evangelism Series Ev49, Cambridge: Grove Books.
Reflections on the nature of church with
illustrations of initiatives ranging from three nuns who started working on an
estate and ended up with a ‘church’ to groups which met in each others’ homes to
children-led groups. Argues that the margins are where the creative stuff is
happening.
Originally titled, "Reimagining
Spiritual Formation" this is an inspiring account of the life
of Solomon’s Porch, a new church in Minneapolis. By telling stories of how the
church tries to engage with people in new ways the pastor, Doug Pagitt, shows us
how they approach spiritual formation through worship, hospitality, physicality,
dialogue, hospitality, bible study, creativity and service. What gives the book
an added depth is the diary entries from a number of SP members. These mostly
confirm but sometimes contradict what Doug is writing.
Fresh Expressions & The Future of Church: Background and Theory
[TOP]
This is another 'catch-all' section, where I
put anything related to Fresh Expressions or emerging church which doesn't seem
to fit anywhere else. Most of the items here are reflections on the theology and
theory underpinning new ways of doing church. It would be worth looking at the
'Postmodern Theology' section as well.
Church of England report,
surveying a range of ‘emerging church’ initiatives (they prefer the term ‘fresh
expressions of church’) and making some suggestions for the future shape of the
church. It has
been hugely influential and is still an excellent introduction to the whole area
of missional church.
In some sense a follow-up to ‘The Shaping of Things to Come’, Frost
explores some of the implications of living missionally in a post-Christian
culture in four sections: dangerous memories, dangerous promises, dangerous
criticism and dangerous songs. Frost is part of a new monastic community called
‘smallboatbigsea’ which has a rule of life known as BELLS: they will Bless at
least one other member of the community each day; they will Eat together every
Sunday evening and with one or more members on two more occasions each week;
they will Listen to God every day; they Learn from the Gospels each week; and
remember that they are Sent into the world to share the Good News.
Stimulating and provocative book
which urges a change from Christendom mode to missional mode. This involves
moving from being attractional, dualistic and hierarchical to incarnational,
messianic and apostolic. Although a little heavy at times the book is full of
ideas and provocative propositions. For instance, a missional church needs APEPT
leadership (apostolic, prophetic, evangelical, pastoral and teaching) as per
Ephesians 4, rather than just a pastoral and teaching leadership which serves to
(try to) maintain the status quo of the Christendom church.
Sally was a member of the team which produced
the Mission-Shaped Church report and has practical experience of fresh
expressions in the countryside. She is aware of the particular issues facing the
rural church but she does not exaggerate them. The book recognises the power of
inherited expressions in the countryside and argues strongly for the mixed
economy—we should nurture inherited church and also start fresh expressions for
those who would not be at home with traditional styles.
The book is very practical, full of case
studies and stories of rural initiatives. There is enough to encourage anyone in
the countryside that change and growth are possible with prayer, faith and hope;
plus a fair amount of perseverance. Sally also offers some useful thoughts on
how to restructure the church for mission in the countryside.
This is a very useful book. It offers a good
introduction to the principles and practice behind mission-shaped church and
will be of particular use to anyone who is in rural ministry or who just has a
passion to see the church grow in the countryside.
Excellent book, which analyses UK
church attendance statistics (especially C of E from 1989-1998) to go beneath
the overall figure of decline. Jackson points out that one in five churches is
either static or growing; that small churches are more likely to be growing than
large ones; that growth can be found across all styles of churchmanship;
ethnically mixed churches are more likely to grow; children's & youth workers have
a major impact on attendance; that growth is most likely when the incumbent has
served between seven and thirteen years and when the incumbent is younger.
Jackson offers practical suggestions to encourage all congregations to face and
tackle the issue of decline.
George offers a number of models
to help with thinking about mission-shaped church, including Acts 1:8—Judea,
Samaria and the end of the earth., which corresponds to the fringe, the
dechurched and the unchurched. His concern is that too much of what passes for
fresh expressions & mission-shaped church is actually working only in Judea.
Very stimulating and challenging.
Summary of ‘Mission-Shaped Church’ with commentary.
A
stimulating collection with papers ranging from those enthusiastic in different
ways about fresh
expressions and emerging church (Stephen Croft, Louise Nelstrop, Sara Savage
etc) to the sceptical (Martyn Percy) and critical (Pete Rollins). I got
something out of every contribution and reading this book broadened my horizons
and helped sharpen my focus on what we are trying to do in Xpressions Cafe.
In
1981 Tom Sine wrote a book called "The Mustard Seed Conspiracy" in which he
painted a grim picture of the future unless individuals behaved like the mustard
seed and conspired to bring the kingdom into being. In this book he continues by
looking at the new forms of church arising throughout the world (but mainly
focused on the US). Sine suggests that there are four kinds of new church
movement: Missional (most Fresh Expressions would come into this category),
Emerging (alternative worship, etc.), Mosaic (black, hip hop, multicultural) and
Monastic ('new monasticism'). It's an interesting typology and is backed up with
some good stories and illustrations.
Ward, Pete 2002, Liquid Church ,
Peabody, MA: Hendrickson & Carlisle: Paternoster.
Stimulating and provocative book. Stresses
fellowship rather than ‘the’ fellowship. Solid church focuses on attendance at
services, size matters, one size fits all and joining the club. Liquid church is
networked, dispersed, consumer-oriented and evanescent. Following Dunn’s views
on Paul, Ward sees the importance of the phrase “in Christ” to suggest that
anyone in Christ is in the church, so that the church can effectively be thought
of as a star network with Christ as the hub. Shopping is seen as a search for
meaning rather than materialism—the church should accept the challenge. Liquid
church moves from meeting need (the need for God, etc.) to satisfying
desire—since consumerism is essentially about desire for meaning and
spirituality.
'Healthy Church' Development
[TOP]
Natural Church
Development, developed by Christian Schwarz, is an approach to church growth
which argues that paying attention to some key areas of church life will
naturally lead to healthier congregations. Robert Warren has developed his own
version.
A
critique of Christian Schwarz’s ‘Natural Church Development’ which argues that
churches will grow if they are healthy in eight dimensions: empowering
leadership; gift-oriented lay ministry; passionate spirituality; functional
structures; inspiring worship services; holistic small groups; need-oriented
evangelism; and loving relationships. These are measured by means of a
computer-marked questionnaire. A key principle is that churches should work on
their lowest scoring dimension since this is a limiting factor. Booker offers a
couple of case studies as well as some criticisms of the approach. He is broadly
sympathetic and supportive.
Healthy
Churches are Growing Churches. That is the premise of Robert Warren's Healthy
Churches' Handbook. Using a
similar approach to Christian Schwarz’s Natural Church Development (NCD), Warren
suggests that healthy churches will be strong in seven values, goals and
characteristics (as opposed to eight activities in NCD). These are: energised by
faith; outward-looking focus; seeks to find what God wants; faces the cost of
change and growth; operates as a community; makes room for all; and does a few
things and does them well.
The
second part of the book contains practical material to help churches become more
healthy, including a questionnaire which enables you to develop a profile of
your church and to see which areas need the most work. Robert Warren is an
experienced mission-oriented priest (he was team rector of St Thomas, Crookes at
the time of the Nine O'Clock Service) and much of the material was developed
while he was involved with the Church of England's Springboard project.
Leadership
[TOP]
Leadership in new forms of church cannot
replicate the traditional 'vicar knows best' command and control approach. This
is so out of kilter with postmodern ideas of participative inquiry that new
forms of church leadership must evolve.
Dawswell,
Andrew 2003,
Ministry Leadership Teams, Grove Pastoral Series P93, Cambridge:
Grove Books.
Written
by one who is in favour of the principle of shared leadership but sceptical
about many of its manifestations. It sometimes seems that he protests against a
rather shallow view of ministry teams but his warnings should be heeded by
everyone who is starry-eyed about the ease and effectiveness of collaborative
leadership. An accompanying
website offers more background and detail.
"Who can lead new churches? Lay leaders exist
across the spectrum of emerging churches. As many as one third of church plants
have been lay led. Is this a welcome throwing off of the shackles of
clericalism? Does it work? Where it has proved too much, can we make church
simpler? "
Shaw,
Peter 2004,
Mirroring Jesus as a Leader, Grove Ethics Series E135,
Cambridge: Grove Books.
Skilton,
Chris 1999, Leadership Teams: Clergy and Lay Leadership in the Local Church,
Grove Pastoral Series P78, Cambridge: Grove Books.
Does
not appear to be currently available
Williams,
Richard & Tanner, Mark 2004,
Developing Visionary Leadership, Grove
Renewal Series R17, Cambridge: Grove Books.
"Visionary Leadership is a gift of God given to
enable churches to grow and express the life of the kingdom. But what is
involved in developing vision, and what skills are needed to turn vision into
reality? This study, the collaboration of a church leader and a business leader,
outlines the key issues, obstacles and ways forward."
Network Church
[TOP]
Traditional Church of England has a
geographical focus. Network churches are supposed to be focused around networks
of interest (which is a bit odd because networks don't have a focus). In
practice there is usually a network component in most traditional parishes.
Perhaps the distinction is about relative strength of the network and
geographical components.
Lings,
George 2000b,
New Canterbury Tales, “Encounters on the Edge 7”, Sheffield:
The Church Army.
Accounts of two network churches in Canterbury
diocese—The Carpenter’s Arms in Deal & Harvest in Margate.
Lings,
George 2003a,
Net Gains, “Encounters on the Edge 19”, Sheffield: The
Church Army.
Studies of
two network churches—The
Net in Huddersfield & B1
in Birmingham—both of which were formed with strong diocesan involvement.
Lings,
George 2009a,
Do Network Churches Work?, “Encounters on the Edge
41”, Sheffield: The
Church Army.
A review and reflection of the position of a number
of network churches. Using some good figures from Harvest New Anglican Church in
Margate (see Encounters No. 7) Lings analyses the nature of network church
noting, for instance, that network church has a much smaller fringe than
geographical church. Network churches appear to have a higher than average
turnover and need to be equipped to cope with that. In particular because the
strength of a network depends more on its few highly connected hubs rather than
the overall number of nodes (members), the loss of key people can be very
damaging.
New Monasticism
[TOP]
In a letter to his brother, written in
1935, Dietrich Boenhoffer said, "The restoration of the church must surely come
from a new type of monasticism, which will have only one thing in common with
the old, a life lived without compromise according to the Sermon on the Mount in
the following of Jesus. I believe the time has come to gather people together
for this." New Monasticism is an umbrella term given a range of initiatives
designed to find ways of living a truly Christ-like life in a postmodern context.
Dalpra, Clare 2008a,
Chasing the Dream: Starting Community,
“Encounters on the Edge 37”, Sheffield: The Church Army.
"Many
of us long to be part of a church that goes beyond mere shallow acquaintance to
caring for one another as lives are shared together. Is this kind of community
as elusive as sometimes it can seem? What can we learn from intentional
Christian communities that have turned the dream into reality? What would they
say were the classic mistakes to avoid? How does community aid them in their
mission task? What will help us plant fresh expressions of church whose
community life is authentic?"
"What
might help the communities in fresh expressions of church grow beyond good
starts to longer lasting effectiveness? What can we learn from intentional
Christian communities that will help fresh expressions of church grow mature
community? What were their catalysts for deeper growth? What would they say were
indicators of a mature community? What level of personal cost does being part of
such a community require of us?"
Lings, George 2006a,
Northumbria Community: Matching Monastery and Mission, "Encounters on
the Edge 29", Sheffield: The Church Army.
The Northumbria
Community is a 'new monastic' group; it is dispersed rather than focused on
communal living. They have also, like similar groups, dispensed with (or
reinterpreted) the vows of chastity and poverty.
After some reflections on the rise of
new monasticism, Lings gives an account of the history and development of the
Northumbria Community. He then suggests that the Community offers a number of
gifts to the wider church, which are characterised by pairs of words:
availability and vulnerability; alone and together; monastery and mission; abbot
and bishop; worship and charism.
George Lings is a
companion in the Northumbria and spent a sabbatical there and with the Anglican
Franciscans at Hilfield in Dorset in September 2009. He also visited Taize and
Citeaux. Out of his experiences he proposes that monastic community has seven
spaces—Cell; Chapel; Chapter; Cloister; Garden; Refectory; Scriptorium—and that
each has a vital part to play. Lings examines the role of each and their part in
the monastic rules of life. He also argues that, "God always raises up the
monastic to show the Church what it sould look more like." (p 32)
The seven spaces could be
a useful lens for looking at Fresh Expressions. For instance, when a group of
ordinands came to Xpressions cafe, one said that he would have a problem doing
what we did as their church hall was 100 yards away from the church (ours are
joined). I suggested that he make the walk part of the experience. The notion of
cloister would have been useful here. Indeed, as we look to build community, I
can see some, but not all, of the seven spaces in Xpressions Cafe. Can and
should we try to add the others? There are
further
resources on the Encounters website including a comprehensive set of notes.
There is also an issue of
The Sheffield Centre Research Bulletin dedicated to this topic, where each
of the seven members of the team reflect on one of the seven spaces.
Ray Simpson is the founder of the Community of
Aidan and Hilda and lives on Lindisfarne. He provides a comprehensive history of
the new monasticism starting in the 1930s with Bonhoeffer,
Iona and
Taizé, and
running through five different waves coming up to date with
24-7 Prayer, the
Eden Project and
Monos. He
then outlines some visions for the future, including the 'Village of God' where
the new monastic community is central to a web of interconnections within the
wider community.
Postmodern Theology
[TOP]
I don't really know what postmodern theology
is but this seemed as good a title as any for some of the works which have been
foundational in the development of the emerging church, as well as others which
help to add to the rich mix.
"This provocative
addition to "The Church and Postmodern Culture" series offers a lively rereading
of Charles Sheldon's "In His Steps" as a constructive way forward. John D.
Caputo introduces the notion of why the church needs deconstruction, positively
defines deconstruction's role in renewal, deconstructs idols of the church, and
imagines the future of the church in addressing the practical implications of
this for the church's life through liturgy, worship, preaching, and teaching.
Students of philosophy, theology, religion, and ministry, as well as others
interested in engaging postmodernism and the emerging church phenomenon, will
welcome this provocative, non-technical work."
Barbara Glasson is a
Methodist minister. She started 'Somewhere Else', usually known as the 'bread
church' in Liverpool. There, in rooms above a radical bookshop in the heart of
Liverpool, people come together to make bread and also sometimes to study, pray
and worship together. What makes the bread church special is its inclusiveness
and the depth of conversation and sharing which is engendered by the act of
bread making. Barbara Glasson has now moved on and this book is a series of
reflections on community and what it is to be church, based around the process
of making bread. Do not expect to find too many facts or details about how
Somewhere Else actually operates or its history. Instead, let Barbara confront
you with a vision of God's kingdom which may be uncomfortable to some but which
I found inspiring and challenging.
Horseman,
Colin 1996,
Good News for a Postmodern World, Grove Evangelism Series
Ev35, Cambridge: Grove Books.
Exploration of postmodernism and
Christian responses to it. “…I was brought up to believe that everything
essential to the gospel…was present in the New Testament, I still believe that,
but in a different way…Rather it is like a seed which contains the whole plant
but which unfolds different aspects at different times.
The fictional account of conversations between Dan,
a disillusioned pastor, and Neo his guide and mentor into the world of postmodern
Christianity. Very readable.
An exposition, with Dan & Neo from ‘A New Kind of
Christian’ of the story we find ourselves in—Creation, Crisis, Calling (of
Abraham & Jews), Conversation (with priests, prophets, poets & philosophers),
Christ, Community (of the church) and Consummation. Tends towards a kind of
universalism or justification by works in its final stages but has many striking
insights and offers a way of inviting people to make sense of their own lives by
seeing them as part of this greater story.
The third and final part of the
'New Kind of Christian' series.
An excellent popular account of
'kingdom theology' and an exploration of some of its implications.
Murray, Stuart 2004,
Post-Christendom: Church and Mission in a Strange New World (After Christendom) , Milton Keynes:
Paternoster.
Stuart Murray is an
Anabaptist and writes from a radical non-establishment perspective. He documents
the rise and fall of Christendom and notes a number of shifts which are now
happening. The church, he argues, is moving centre to margins; from majority to
minority; from settlers to sojourners; from privilege to plurality; from control
to witness; from maintenance to mission; and from institution to movement. It's
a penetrating analysis which needs to be heeded by the church.
Rollins, Peter 2006,
How (not) to Speak of God ,
London: SPCK.
I loved this book. It's in two
parts: the first looks at the nature of God and how we might know/encounter him;
the second gives a number of 'scripts' from sessions of Ikon, an alternative
worship community in Belfast, of which Rollins is a leader. Pete Rollins teaches
philosophy and brings interesting insights to this book. Rollins starts with two
epigrams, one from Wittgenstein, the other from his charismatic evangelical
background: "What we cannot speak about we must pass over in silence." and
"GodHe argues for a apophatic approach to God—that we cannot ever know about God
but that we can experience God. He sees Christianity as a/theistic, citing
Anselm, amongst others, on his side: "Therefore, Lord, you are not merely that
than which a greater cannot be thought: you are something greater than can be
thought."
This sense of radically engaged
unknowing pervades the book. Rollins dissolves the debate between the
transcendence and immamence of God by asserting that God is immament and it is
the brilliance of his closeness which leads us to experience Him as
transcendent, just a really bright light will blind us.
"The philosophies of French thinkers Derrida,
Lyotard, and Foucault form the basis for postmodern thought and are seemingly at
odds with the Christian faith. However, James K. A. Smith claims that their
ideas have been misinterpreted and actually have a deep affinity with central
Christian claims. Each chapter opens with an illustration from a recent movie
and concludes with a case study considering recent developments in the church
that have attempted to respond to the postmodern condition, such as the
"emerging church" movement. These case studies provide a concrete picture of how
postmodern ideas can influence the way Christians think and worship. This
significant book, winner of a Christianity Today 2007 Book Award, avoids
philosophical jargon and offers fuller explanation where needed. It is the first
book in the Church and Postmodern Culture series, which provides practical
applications for Christians engaged in ministry in a postmodern world."
Ward, Pete 2002, Liquid Church ,
Peabody, MA: Hendrickson & Carlisle: Paternoster.
Stimulating and provocative book. Stresses
fellowship rather than ‘the’ fellowship. Solid church focuses on attendance at
services, size matters, one size fits all and joining the club. Liquid church is
networked, dispersed, consumer-oriented and evanescent. Following Dunn’s views
on Paul, Ward sees the importance of the phrase “in Christ” to suggest that
anyone in Christ is in the church, so that the church can effectively be thought
of as a star network with Christ as the hub. Shopping is seen as a search for
meaning rather than materialism—the church should accept the challenge. Liquid
church moves from meeting need (the need for God, etc.) to satisfying
desire—since consumerism is essentially about desire for meaning and
spirituality.
The Bishop of Durham may be
surprised to see himself categorised here as a 'postmodern theologian' and I do
not intend to so pigeonhole him. But there is no doubt that his work is hugely
influential in the thinking of emerging church leaders such as Jonny Baker and
Brian McLaren. This book is one of Tom Wright's masterpieces - a 'must read' for
anyone who is grappling with the meaning of Christianity.
Preaching
[TOP]
Preaching can be effective in a postmodern
context but it needs to resonate with the culture. For that reason I suggest
that the three key emphases should be Story, Testimony and Performance. The
books below follow up some of these themes.
Performance has always been important in preaching; today it is even more
so. I rate it as one of the three key aspects of effective preaching to a 21st
century audience—the triumvirate being story, testimony and performance. Jana
Childers offers insights from the theatre to illumine the preacher’s art. She
addresses a number of topics including preaching and dramatic form; preaching as
performance; preaching and the creative process; skills preachers can learn from
actors; attitudes preachers can learn from the actors ‘habitus’ (‘body
techniques’) and worship as theatre. As well as discussion of the links between
preaching and theatre, Childers also offers a lot of practical advice on such
areas as breathing, articulation, eye contact and so on. A useful book which
will proved a good resource for any preacher wishing to engage better with his
or her listeners.
Florence, Anna Carter 2007, Preaching as Testimony , Louisville & London: Westminster John Knox Press.
A brilliant, rich, and thought-provoking book. Anna Carter Florence
explores the rich heritage of women preachers in the US. Partly because of their
lack of learning and their lack of formal authority they learned to preach from
the heart, sharing their own responses to the text. Florence explores the work of some of these preachers, draws on Ricoeur
and Brueggemann and offers some practical approaches to preaching as testimony,
which she argues is an invitation to believe rather than a command to obey.
Testimony preaching is not about the preacher; it is much more than simply
talking about your own life and experiences. It is all about God’s word; it is
about what happened to you when you encountered this text at this time—what did
you really see or experience, rather than what your training or the commentaries
or your concept of orthodoxy tells you that you ought to have seen or
experienced.
There are some really practical tips and exercises offered to help with a
three part process. Firstly, attend to the text, live in it. Florence offers a
number of exercises to help, including writing the text out, carrying it in your
pocket, memorising it, underlining words & phrases which strike you and so on. Next describe the text by making a list of the images which appear and
reflecting on them, or write a dialogue between the characters, or even rewrite
it the way you would like it to have been! Finally, testify. Reflect on your own response and decide how much to
share, how much you dare, how much your listeners can bear. Testimony preaching
is risky—perhaps too risky for some preachers and some congregations—but can be
a great way of connecting with those postmodern people who reject authority but
who respond to authentic testimony.
Johnston, Graham 2001,
Preaching to a Postmodern World: A Guide to Reaching Twenty-first Century Listeners , Grand
Rapids, MI: Baker Books.
After an
examination of what postmodernity means, Johnston offers four ‘rules for
engagement’: don’t engage at the expense of the message; communication takes
two—and time; risk involvement; address where you live. He continues with
chapters on challenging listeners; obstacles to postmodern preaching; how to
make inroads into contemporary culture; and some practices for engagement.
Jones, Kirk Byron 2004,
The Jazz of Preaching: How to Preach with Great Freedom and Joy , Nashville: Abingdon
Press.
Do you read your sermon from a prepared
text? Is everything you preach ‘nailed down’ before you start speaking? If so,
how can the Holy Spirit ever get through to lead and inspire you in the moment
of delivery? (Maybe that thought is just too scary!) On the other hand, do you just ‘let it
all hang out’, arriving with just a vague idea of what you intend to say? If so,
how can you hope to have your listeners come with you on your journey without
getting either lost or seasick? Kirk Jones might argue that jazz offers a way
through this dilemma. Jazz is structured and disciplined yet free and
improvisatory. Byron argues that preachers can learn a lot from listening to
jazz and studying the way jazz musicians work.
I am not a great fan of jazz myself,
blues and some modern jazz being the only forms which I really connect with, but
I find Byron’s arguments persuasive. He stresses the need to preach with freedom
and joy and offers insights into how we might do this, with chapters focusing on
dreaming; creativity; improvisation (I particularly liked the story about Winton
Marsalis and the mobile phone which he recounts on page 80); dialogue; blues and
joy.
Lowry,
Eugene 2001, The Homiletical Plot: The Sermon as Narrative Art Form , Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox Press.
Eugene Lowry is Professor of Homiletics at He is also a preacher and a
jazz pianist - the latter two being not unconnected. He has written a number of
books on narrative preaching, of which this is the best known. The Homiletical Plot suggests that preachers should structure
their sermons according to the basic structure which underpins many stories.
After all, Jesus told stories far more often than he gave three-point sermons!
According to Lowry's scheme the basic narrative plot has five parts:
Oops!--upsetting the equilibrium; Ugh!--analysing the discrepancy;
Aha!--disclosing the clue to resolution; Whee!--experiencing the gospel; and
Yeah!--anticipating the consequences. Lowry explains these in the chapters which form the heart of the book.
It's good but it's a bit too theoretical for my
taste. I would have liked some examples of sermons which used the format; these
would have helped bring the ideas to life. I have never constructed a sermon in
exactly the way that Lowry outlines; nevertheless, I do sometimes use his schema
to check the structure of my own sermons and I find that they often follow his
structure. In such cases the book can be useful for refining what I've already
done. Overall a good book; any preacher will benefit from reading it.
I encourage my students to preach
without notes. They are often horrified at first but when they give it a try
many find the benefits. Lybrand argues that there is nothing in the Bible to
support preaching with notes; all the examples are to the contrary. He claims
that 'preaching on your feet' can be learned by anyone, rather than being an
innate skill gifted only to a few. There are number of pre-determined
structures, or templates, which can help the noteless preacher - without a clear
sense of structure there is danger of wandering off or drying up. Preaching
without notes facilitates good performance, which is so important in a
postmodern context; whoever came across a stand-up comedian who used notes?
Lybrand is not really concerned with postmodern preaching, however, and I found
the book a bit dry and too focused on great preachers of the past such as
Spurgeon. Nevertheless there are some good tips here.
Mark Miller is the founder of ‘The Jesus
Journey’, an experiential retreat. He argues that the postmodern generation
needs more than the traditional sermon. His suggestion is the experiential
story—a presentation where attention is paid to environment, engagement of all
the senses, use of symbols and participation by the ‘congregation’. Thus the
sermon becomes more of an event or a happening. There are some good ideas but
for some reason I was a bit underwhelmed by this
book.
Standing,
Roger 2002,
Preaching for the Unchurched in an Entertainment Culture,
Grove Evangelism Series Ev58, Cambridge: Grove Books.
Drawing on Standing’s experience of youth
services, looks at changes in communication style & importance of narrative.
Gives results of a small experiment into perceived differences between topical
and expository styles of preaching (younger people prefer topical) and impact of
multimedia (helps memory retention). Standing explores narrative preaching in some
detail, including a lengthy section on Lowry’s work. The book contains a number
of sample narrative sermons and also contains insights from a number of
interviews which Standing conducted with narrative preachers. [This may no
longer be available.]
Thomson makes a clear distinction
between preaching and sermon. By looking at preaching as a social phenomenon and
examining the setting and format of the interaction between the participants he
argues that the monologue was rarely the form in which preaching occurred in the
New testament. The sermon was a later social development which needs now to be
challenged. God's relationship with humans is essentially dialogic and so must
our preaching be. One implication is an extension of our common views on
preaching: the conversations in a mid-week small group about a Bible text are as
much preaching as any set piece sermon on a Sunday morning. Furthermore, the
Sunday sermon must be repented of and reformed so that dialogue becomes a
natural and productive part of our preaching life.
Small
Groups in Church
[TOP]
Small groups are often the life blood of a
growing church. Two distinct forms of small group, each of which has its own
section in this bibliography, are base ecclesial communities and cell groups.
This section 'mops up' works relating to other small groups in church life.
An Anglican perspective on small
communities in church growth and development. He distinguishes ‘family
churches’, with fewer than 50 members from ‘pastoral churches’ with more than 50
members. A family church with a full-timer minister may well grow. Others, with
only one full-time minister are likely to decline. Therefore small groups are
needed to sustain and grow the church. The purpose of a transforming community
is to build members’ relationships, to learn together and to support each
others’ ministries, sometimes in pursuit of a common task. These groups are to
be the ‘building blocks’ of the church. Croft’s communities are not as radically
mission-focused as cell church, nor as justice focused as base communities. At
times seems a bit like an Anglican fudge!
Frazee comments on rising tide of
individualism in the church. He argues the need for a common purpose based
around authority, common creed, traditions, standards and common mission. In his
church they are working this out by agreeing ten core beliefs, ten core
practices and ten core virtues. They then implement these via a four-fold
process: the worship service which is to inspire; the Sunday mid-sized groups
(50) which are to instruct; mid-week small groups (10) which involve; and
personal introspection.
Really interesting book about medium-sized
communities (between cell and congregation) which exist for a specific
mission-focused purpose. Clusters developed in St Thomas, Crookes in Sheffield.
According to the book, "Clusters gain identity and purpose from a united mission
vision, being called to a clear geographic or network focus and engaging with
the social patterns of that culture and context." (p. [6]) Members of a cluster
will probably belong to different cell group or different congregations because
they are chosen (often self-selecting) on the basis of shared interest. The book
offers case studies of a number of different implementations of the cluster
principle.
Mallison argues that the small
group is the basic building block of the life of the local congregation. It has
seven basic purposes: to worship & obey Christ; to live under the authority of
God’s Word; to be havens of hope; to foster fellowship; to bring people to a
living faith in Christ; to minister to each other; to prepare each other for
mission in the world. He distinguishes many kinds of group and offers a lot of
practical advice for working with and in groups, including a dozen different
kinds of Bible study and different ways of praying together. (This book is out
of print now; a search on
Abebooks might help.)
Fascinating book, drawing on the work of Edward Hall
(proxemics) on the different spaces we all inhabit—public, social, personal &
intimate. He argues that we need to be active in all spaces to belong and his
conclusions about the value (or otherwise) of small groups in church life are
very provocative and worthy of thought and discussion.
Spirituality [TOP]
"Spirituality is the game, religion is the
team." Spirituality is increasingly popular, though increasingly vague as a
category. There are lots of people on a spiritual journey; few would think that
they could find spirituality in church.
The first three chapters are from Nick Spencer and
Yvonne Collins, outlining their research with those who have little or no
contact with church. The second part of the collection consists of four
'responses'. Ann Richards looks at contemporary spirituality and the
evangelistic encounter; Mark Ireland offers practical suggestions for the local
church; Rob Frost explores alternative spirituality; and Stephen Croft looks at
listening and speaking in contemporary evangelism.
A six-part course which
introduces Christian ideas and principles in a way which is designed to connect
with those who are seeking ‘spirituality’. Includes a CD of meditations and
music.
Hollinghurst, Steve 2003,
New Age, Paganism and Christian Mission, Grove
Evangelism Series Ev64, Cambridge: Grove Books.
A review of New Age and Pagan
beliefs, showing their similarities and differences. Hollinghurst also offers
some helpful suggestions on ways of connecting with new agers and pagans and how
the gospel might be authentically shared.
An A4 photocopiable
workbook with lots of good ideas and resources. Sections include: The Emerging
Spiritual Age; Listening to the World Around Us; Rites of Passage; Times and
Seasons; Developing the Church as the Spiritual Focus of the Community;
Wholeness and Healing; Going Out to Our Communities; Sacred Britain; Being With
People of Alternative Spiritualities; Moving Into Action. There are also a
number of good and pointed cartoons from Chris Morgan and also the questionnaire
that Yvonne Richmond used for her Beyond the Fringe research.
An excellent reference book, very
comprehensive, with coverage of over 200 sects, cults and new religious
movements. If you're not sure about the difference between Ramakrishna,
Krishnamurti and Hare Krishna then this is the place to find out. If you want to
explore some of the different kinds of paganism or see how "The Celestine
Prophecy" differs from "A Course in Miracles", that's here too. It's fascinating
and enlightening.
Sylvan, Rob 2005,
Trance Formation , London: Routledge.
A
fascinating book in which the author explores the spiritual aspects of rave
culture. Sylvan did his doctorate looking at the African tribal religious roots
of rock music. When he became involved in the rave scene in the US her decided
to do some research. He suggests that rave culture has seven characteristics:
A combination of sacred and secular; Expression within the arts;
Expression within popular culture; Emphasis on experience over content;
The central importance of the body; Use of digital technology, multimedia, and
global communication systems; and Postmodern, hybrid, cut-and-past nature. The
similarities with some alternative worship values will be no surprise, given the
roots of the alternative worship movement.
Youth
& Children's Church [TOP]
Do young people need their own form of church?
If so, what happens when they grow older? This section deals with expressions of
church specifically focused on those who are pre-adult (well, up to 30, really).
Clark,
Philip & Pearson, Geoff 2001 (2nd ed),
Kidz Klubs: The Alpha of Children’s
Evangelism? Grove Evangelism Series Ev45, Cambridge: Grove Books.
Dalpra, Clare 2006,
Small Beginnings: Church for Under 5's, “Encounters on the Edge 31”,
Sheffield: The Church Army.
"What fresh expressions of church are beginning among under 5s and their
families? Why can’t we simply invite them to existing church? How is
spirituality nurtured in children of this age? When does work with under 5s
qualify as a fresh expression of church and what do they have to teach us?"
Lings,
George 1999,
Eternity—The Beginning, “Encounters on the Edge 4”,
Sheffield: The Church Army.
Looks at the work of
Eternity, a youth church plant
in Bracknell. Eternity is values-based and open to constant change. It uses cell
groups, monthly congregational gatherings and events which are designed for
seekers to be comfortable in (they moved from café-style to dance-style because
that seemed to be where the young people were going).
Lings,
George 2001,
Never on a Sunday?, “Encounters on the Edge 11”, Sheffield:
The Church Army.
Looks at a couple of midweek (Monday, actually)
afternoon congregations which serve primary school kids and their parents. Asks whether
they are churches or congregations. Argues that there are many people for whom
Sunday church is not an option.
Lings,
George 2004,
Reading: the Signs, “Encounters on the Edge 21”, Sheffield:
The Church Army.
The rather messy story of the
development of a youth ministry to unchurched young people in Reading. Based in
a traditional church building with a small declining conservative congregation
the young curate (effectively vicar of the church) has been enabled by the
rector and the diocese to perform some innovative youth ministry and church
planting (though he eschews this term).
Savage, Collins & Mayo
interviewed 135 young people, mainly between the ages of 15 and 25, in 26 focus
groups throughout England. Of these, 52% were female, 48% male; 94% were white,
6% Black or Asian; 60% defined themselves as non-Christian, 40% as Christian.
Their findings showed significant differences between this generation and those
which preceded it. For instance, researchers have often spoken of a hunger for
spirituality in Gen-X and Boomer people—a ‘God-shaped hole’ in their lives. None
was found for the Gen-Y young people in this study. Instead, the major finding
was of what they call a ‘happy midi-narrative’: “My aim to be happy will be
realised through me being myself, and connecting to others and the universe
(without harming them). As I do this, I will create a meaningful and happy life.
This happiness is meaningful in itself; it is the Ideal." They also look at what
is absent (God, religion, romance, fear of death, sin, etc.) from the happiness
narrative and what is present in it (family, friends, celebrity, caring for
life, etc.). The key importance of soap operas, music and clubbing are also
noticed and commented on.
Sylvan, Rob 2005,
Trance Formation
, London: Routledge.
A
fascinating book in which the author explores the spiritual aspects of rave
culture. Sylvan did his doctorate looking at the African tribal religious roots
of rock music. When he became involved in the rave scene in the US her decided
to do some research. He suggests that rave culture has seven characteristics:
A combination of sacred and secular; Expression within the arts;
Expression within popular culture; Emphasis on experience over content;
The central importance of the body; Use of digital technology, multimedia, and
global communication systems; and Postmodern, hybrid, cut-and-past nature. The
similarities with some alternative worship values will be no surprise, given the
roots of the alternative worship movement.
|